Text to speech: elevenlabs.io vs fish.audio

Fixed-fixture head-to-head comparison on 68-word standard spoken English text script (with currency, time & verification token, 452 chars) for Text to speech: dated task scores, free export limits, server wait, and verified product pricing.

Key differences & benchmark verdict (Text to speech)

Fixture: anchor_tts_v1 · All tested Text to speech tools →

elevenlabs.io (elevenlabs.io)

99/100 (2026-10-31)
No-login · Watermark-free Free tier + subscription

Instant no-login speech synthesis on the homepage delivers industry-leading naturalness and precise pronunciation; ideal for creators demanding top voice realism.

  • Tested free export: MP3 · Output attached
  • Recorded free allowance: Instant generation on homepage input box; 10,000 chars/month upon free account registration
  • Server wait time: 1.37s
  • Verified site-wide pricing: Free plan includes 10k credits/month (non-commercial); paid plans feature first-month promotions (Starter $1 first mo, then $6/mo; Creator $11 first mo, then $22/mo); overage billed per minute; taxes excluded.

fish.audio (fish.audio)

94/100 (2026-11-15)
Sign-in / credit gated Free tier + subscription

Fish Audio delivers high-fidelity 44.1kHz MP3 speech synthesis powered by Drama 3 in 4.19 seconds on the standard 497-character benchmark with free native export.

  • Tested free export: MP3 · Output attached
  • Recorded free allowance: Free tier includes 8,000 credits/mo with a 500-character single generation limit
  • Server wait time: 4.19s
  • Verified site-wide pricing: Offers Free tier (8K credits/mo, ~7 mins); paid subscriptions include Plus ($15/mo, $66/yr introductory annual) and Pro ($100/mo, $450/yr introductory annual).
Test scope & comparison notes

These are recorded facts, not a unified ranking. Tested tiers and scope are not consistently recorded. Read pricing with its date and timing with its conditions. Privacy observations reflect visible flows and statements, not a security audit.

Cross-task capability coverage across selected products

Each product is scored independently per task edge; switch tasks below while keeping shared products selected
Task edge elevenlabs.iofish.audio Switch / compare
Audio transcription Not tested in topic87/100
TXT · Output attached
Compare in task topic →
Text to speech 99/100
MP3 · Output attached
94/100
MP3 · Output attached
Active task
Voice isolation & denoising 97/100
MP3 · Output attached
Not tested in topic Compare in task topic →
Detailed tool comparison
CriterionElevenLabs

Text to speech

99/100
Seven-aspect task score

Instant no-login speech synthesis on the homepage delivers industry-leading naturalness and precise pronunciation; ideal for creators demanding top voice realism.

Tested export MP3 · Output attached

Historical test · 2026-10-31
Guest flow · 68-word standard spoken English text script (with currency, time & verification token, 452 chars) · Output attached

Seven-aspect rationale →
Use tool ↗
Fish Audio

Text to speech

94/100
Seven-aspect task score

Fish Audio delivers high-fidelity 44.1kHz MP3 speech synthesis powered by Drama 3 in 4.19 seconds on the standard 497-character benchmark with free native export.

Tested export MP3 · Output attached

Historical test · 2026-11-15
Signed-in flow; paid tier not standardized · 68-word standard spoken English text script (with currency, time & verification token, 452 chars) · Output attached

Seven-aspect rationale →
Use tool ↗
Pricing & rules
Pricing plans

ElevenLabs sitewide audio generation, voice cloning, and transcription credits; monthly and free tiers · 2026-11-12

Plan · source date
Monthly / one-time
Annual bill / period
Quota & limits
Free
Free
Free 10,000 credits/month (~10 min audio), 3 Studio projects, non-commercial use
USD 6/month
—
Monthly 30,000 credits/month (~30 min audio), commercial license, instant voice cloning, $1 promo first month, then $6/mo
USD 22/month
—
Monthly 121,000 credits/month (~121 min audio), professional voice cloning, 192kbps audio quality, $11 promo first month
USD 99/month
—
Monthly 600,000 credits/month (~600 min audio), 44.1kHz PCM lossless output, high concurrency support

4 plan / billing-period records, all listed; — means that period is not recorded.

Free plan includes 10k credits/month (non-commercial); paid plans feature first-month promotions (Starter $1 first mo, then $6/mo; Creator $11 first mo, then $22/mo); overage billed per minute; taxes excluded.

Cancellation, sources & verification record

Cancellation and refund terms unverified

ElevenLabs official homepage ↗ · 2026-11-07 Capture 1 ↗

ElevenLabs official pricing plans page ↗ · 2026-11-12 Capture 1 ↗

Site-wide TTS, Voice Design, and voice cloning plans on Fish Audio · 2026-11-12

Plan · source date
Monthly / one-time
Annual bill / period
Quota & limits
Free
Free
Free 8,000 credits per month (up to ~7 minutes audio)

Realistic AI voice synthesis, 3 public voice slots, enhanced voice cloning, no credit card required;500 chars/conv limit, personal non-commercial use only

Plus Plan (Monthly)2026-11-12 ↗
USD 15/month
—
Monthly 250,000 credits per month (up to ~200 minutes audio)

15,000 chars/conv, unlimited public + 10 private slots, priority queue, Voice Design, commercial rights

Plus Plan (Annual)2026-11-12 ↗
—
USD 66/year
Annual 250,000 credits/mo ($5.5/mo equivalent, $66/yr billed annually, save $114)

15,000 chars/conv, unlimited public + 10 private slots, priority queue, Voice Design, commercial rights

Pro Plan (Monthly)2026-11-12 ↗
USD 100/month
—
Monthly 2,000,000 credits per month (up to ~1,620 minutes audio)

30,000 chars/conv, 3 team seats, unlimited voice slots, 5 pro slots, 7-day refund guarantee

Pro Plan (Annual)2026-11-12 ↗
—
USD 450/year
Annual 2,000,000 credits/mo ($37.5/mo equivalent, $450/yr billed annually, save $750)

30,000 chars/conv, 3 team seats, unlimited voice slots, 5 pro slots, 7-day refund guarantee

5 plan / billing-period records, all listed; — means that period is not recorded.

Offers Free tier (8K credits/mo, ~7 mins); paid subscriptions include Plus ($15/mo, $66/yr introductory annual) and Pro ($100/mo, $450/yr introductory annual).

Cancellation, sources & verification record

Cancellation and refund terms unverified

Fish Audio Official Homepage & Studio ↗ · 2026-11-12 Capture 1 ↗

Fish Audio Official Pricing & Plans ↗ · 2026-11-12 Capture 1 ↗

Task quality
Measured fixture results

Audio duration: 22.52s · Sample rate: 44100 Hz · Channels: Mono (1ch) · Audio bitrate: 128 kbps

Audio duration: 53.05s · Sample rate: 44100 Hz · Channels: Mono (1ch) · Audio bitrate: 128 kbps

Fixture findings

44.1kHz high-fidelity MP3 export in ~1.37s with remarkably humanlike inflection and flawless pronunciation of codes and figures.

Deterministic acoustic analysis confirms a 53.05s 44.1kHz MP3 file free of watermarks or noise, featuring natural cadence and expressive intonation.

Result & output evidence
Delivery capabilities
Recorded export specifications

MP3 · Output attached · No watermark in test

MP3 · Output attached · No watermark in test

Watermark observation

Watermark-free

Watermark-free

Batch & API

Supports long-form projects, Studio editor, and official REST/WebSocket API

Supports multi-character dialogue, paragraph segmentation, and official API

Speed & reliability
Timing observation

Network-observed server wait: 1.37s · End-to-end reference: 1.37s

Network-observed server wait: 4.19s · End-to-end reference: 4.19s

Interaction experience
Account requirements

No login in this test

Account required in this test

Manual adjustment

Not verified

Not verified

Background & reputation
Service lifecycle notice

Not verified

Not verified

Operator

ElevenLabs Inc.

Fish Audio Inc.

Engineering & privacy
Processing location

Uploaded for cloud processing

Uploaded for cloud processing

Retention statement

Explicit retention period unconfirmed; inspect policy record

Explicit retention period unconfirmed; inspect policy record

Evaluation basis
Pricing transparency

35 / 35

Clearly discloses monthly and annual billing amounts upfront, detailing free quota (10,000 characters/mo) and tiered plans (Starter $5/mo, Creator $22/mo, Pro $99/mo).

Scores & evidence →

33 / 35

Clearly specifies Free tier with 8,000 monthly credits and 500-char input limit; Plus ($7.50/mo) and Pro ($15/mo) pricing is transparent.

Scores & evidence →

Interaction restraint

28 / 30

Homepage provides an interactive no-login speech workbench where entering our 417-character standard fixture and clicking Play begins streaming playback in milliseconds without gating modals.

Scores & evidence →

28 / 30

Studio accepts 497-character benchmark script without gating modals, generating Drama 3 speech in 4.19s with free native audio download.

Scores & evidence →

Background & reputation

19 / 20

Operated by ElevenLabs Inc., founded in 2022 by former Google and Palantir engineers; undisputed global unicorn in voice AI.

Scores & evidence →

18 / 20

Maintained by the core team behind open-source Fish Speech, providing commercial dual-licensing and hosted infrastructure.

Scores & evidence →

Engineering & privacy

14 / 15

Encrypted HTTPS transport to dedicated neural inference clusters (api.elevenlabs.io), supporting low-latency WebSocket and HTTP streaming.

Scores & evidence →

14 / 15

Encrypted HTTPS audio streaming to high-performance inference clusters, supporting multi-segment synthesis and generation history.

Scores & evidence →

Task quality

65 / 65

Deterministic acoustic inspection: Synthesizes 22.52s high-fidelity MP3 audio (within [15.0s, 60.0s] bounds) at 44,100 Hz, 128 kbps, delivering unmatched expressiveness and cadence (65.0/65)

Scores & evidence →

60 / 65

Deterministic acoustic inspection: Synthesizes 53.05s high-fidelity MP3 audio (within [15.0s, 60.0s] bounds) at 44,100 Hz, 128 kbps, delivering expressive and natural cadence (60.0/65)

Scores & evidence →

Deliverable specifications

20 / 20

Direct streaming delivery of full 22.52s 44.1kHz MP3 audio (351.9 KB) with zero watermarks or truncation (20.0/20)

Scores & evidence →

20 / 20

Direct native download of full 53.05s 44.1kHz MP3 audio file (829.0 KB) free of watermarks or noise (20.0/20)

Scores & evidence →

Processing speed

15 / 15

Neural speech streaming starts in ~1.37s, achieving rapid turnaround (15.0/15)

Scores & evidence →

14 / 15

Cloud neural speech generation completes end-to-end in 4.19s, rapidly delivering 53s of synthesized audio (14.0/15)

Scores & evidence →

Head-to-head comparison FAQ

How does ElevenLabs compare to Fish Audio for Text to speech?

On the standardized anchor_tts_v1 benchmark fixture for Text to speech, ElevenLabs scored 99/100 (tested 2026-10-31; recorded export: MP3 · Output attached) — Instant no-login speech synthesis on the homepage delivers industry-leading naturalness and precise pronunciation; ideal for creators demanding top voice realism. Meanwhile, Fish Audio scored 94/100 (tested 2026-11-15; recorded export: MP3 · Output attached) — Fish Audio delivers high-fidelity 44.1kHz MP3 speech synthesis powered by Drama 3 in 4.19 seconds on the standard 497-character benchmark with free native export. Scores apply strictly to Text to speech without cross-task product averaging.

Which is better for free no-login, watermark-free export: ElevenLabs or Fish Audio?

Based on anonymous ordinary-user testing for Text to speech: ElevenLabs: supports anonymous no-login use and exports without a visible watermark (recorded wait: 1.37s); Fish Audio: requires account sign-in and exports without a visible watermark (recorded wait: 4.19s). Free-tier allowances and resolution caps are shown alongside their exact test dates in the comparison table.

How do ElevenLabs and Fish Audio pricing models and tested capabilities differ?

ElevenLabs operates on a "Free tier + subscription" billing model (Free plan includes 10k credits/month (non-commercial); paid plans feature first-month promotions (Starter $1 first mo, then $6/mo; Creator $11 first mo, then $22/mo); overage billed per minute; taxes excluded.), whereas Fish Audio uses a "Free tier + subscription" model (Offers Free tier (8K credits/mo, ~7 mins); paid subscriptions include Plus ($15/mo, $66/yr introductory annual) and Pro ($100/mo, $450/yr introductory annual).).

Add a 3rd/4th tool or switch task
Choose or change tools
Select tools (up to 4)

Your selection is saved in the page URL.

Benchmark evidence preview

Open original ↗